East Texas Orthodontics is losing patients to competitors every single day
This comprehensive audit reveals exactly where patients are being lost, why they're choosing competitors instead, and the precise steps needed to dominate the Tyler orthodontic market.
Digital Health Score Card
A comprehensive assessment across five critical dimensions of digital marketing performance. Each score reflects current competitive position and growth potential.
Competitive Position at Risk
With an overall score of 42/100, East Texas Orthodontics is significantly underperforming compared to local competitors. Without immediate action, the gap will continue to widen as competitors invest in their digital presence.
The hidden cost of standing still
Every day these gaps remain unfixed, potential patients are choosing competitors instead. Here's where the biggest opportunities are being missed.
Every gap in your digital presence is an open door for competitors. When patients can't find you, can't trust you, or can't navigate your site — they go elsewhere.
The Gap Is Widening Every Month
What competitors are doing right
A detailed comparison of the Tyler-area orthodontic market shows exactly where ETO stands and what competitors are doing to capture market share.
What Competitors Do Better
- Systematic review generation — Wilkinson adds ~15 reviews/month consistently
- Optimized Google Business Profiles — Complete info, regular posts, Q&A responses
- Professional ad creative — Emotional imagery, clear value props, strong CTAs
- Consistent NAP data — Same address/phone across all directories
ETO's Competitive Advantages
- 5 convenient locations — More coverage than any single competitor
- #1 in Local Pack — Top position for "orthodontist Tyler TX" searches
- Excellent rating (4.9★) — Quality is there, just need volume
- Established brand — Name recognition in East Texas market
Where patients are being lost
Mapping the patient journey reveals critical leak points where potential patients are choosing competitors or abandoning their search entirely.
Google Search
Patient searches 'orthodontist Tyler TX' — ETO appears #1 in Local Pack. Strong visibility, but the review count (34) immediately stands out against competitors (150-800).
Review Comparison
Patient compares reviews — sees ETO with 34 reviews vs. competitors with 150-800. Social proof deficit causes immediate trust gap.
Website Visit
Patient visits ETO website — encounters full-screen popup immediately. On mobile, navigation links are broken (all point to Canton).
Contact Attempt
Patient tries to call — finds different phone numbers on website vs. Google. Confusion leads to abandonment or calling competitor.
Conversion
Remaining patients who navigate all obstacles successfully book a consultation.
Cumulative Impact
Of every 100 potential patients who start searching for an orthodontist in Tyler, approximately 90 are lost before ever contacting ETO. Fixing these leak points could potentially triple new patient inquiries.
Critical bugs confirmed
Our technical analysis confirmed several critical issues that directly harm user experience and SEO performance.
Mobile Navigation Bug
CriticalIn the mobile menu, all location links incorrectly point to the Canton page. This affects the majority of users who browse on mobile devices.
NAP Inconsistencies
CriticalMultiple Name, Address, and Phone inconsistencies found across the website. These confuse search engines and damage local SEO signals.
Intrusive Interstitials
ConfirmedFull-screen "New Patient Special" overlay and DearDoc chatbot widget create a double-interstitial experience that likely violates Google's policies and harms Core Web Vitals scores.
Current Meta ad is severely underperforming
ETO's current Facebook/Instagram ad uses a static building exterior photo with generic copy. This approach fails to capture attention, convey emotion, or differentiate from competitors.
Current Ad Creative
Poor Performance
Building Exterior Photo
Shows a parking lot and storefront — zero emotional appeal or patient connection
Generic Copy
"Your perfect smile is unique" — bland, forgettable messaging with no clear CTA
No Human Element
No smiling patients, no doctors, no team — fails to build trust or relatability
No Value Proposition
Lists services but doesn't communicate why ETO is the right choice
Professional Alternatives
High ImpactThese professionally designed ad creatives demonstrate what effective orthodontic advertising looks like — featuring real emotions, clear value propositions, and compelling visual design.
"Change How You Walk Into a Room"
- Powerful emotional headline
- Real patient testimonial with stars
- Confident, smiling adult model
"Confident Smiles for Life's Adventures"
- Father-daughter adventure imagery
- Real patient review integration
- Lifestyle-focused messaging
"Confident Smiles" (Family)
- Happy family social proof
- Instagram-style engagement
- Warm, approachable aesthetic
"Your Smile Journey"
- Mother-daughter emotional connection
- Clear value icons (locations, financing)
- Brand-consistent design elements
"Smile Brighter, Texas!"
- Team photo builds trust
- Local Texas identity
- Clear bullet-point benefits
"Your Teen's Confidence"
- Targets parent decision-makers
- Modern office environment
- Emotional benefit (confidence)
Key Takeaway
Professional ad creatives feature real people showing genuine emotion, clear value propositions, and brand-consistent design. ETO's current ad has none of these elements and is likely wasting significant ad spend with poor engagement rates.
The path to market dominance
A week-by-week action plan to fix critical issues, close the competitive gap, and position ETO as the dominant orthodontic practice in East Texas.
Emergency Fixes
- Fix mobile navigation bug (all location links)
- Correct all NAP inconsistencies
- Remove or minimize intrusive popup
- Verify Google Business Profile accuracy
Foundation Building
- Implement systematic review generation process
- Optimize Google Business Profile completely
- Begin responding to all existing reviews
- Audit and fix all citation sources
Content & SEO
- Create dedicated Invisalign service page
- Build out location-specific landing pages
- Add schema markup for local SEO
- Develop content calendar for GBP posts
Growth Acceleration
- Launch professional ad creative campaign
- A/B test ad messaging and targeting
- Monitor and adjust review velocity
- Track Local Pack progress weekly
Expected Outcomes After 90 Days
Things to fix today
These items require minimal effort but will have immediate positive impact. Most can be completed within hours at no cost.
Update Lindale address and phone number
Ensure consistent NAP data across all pages and directories. This directly impacts local SEO signals.
Fix mobile navigation links
Update the mobile menu so each location links to its correct page instead of Canton.
Respond to all Google reviews
Personalized responses to every review (positive and negative) show engagement and build trust.
Remove or delay the popup
Either remove the full-screen interstitial or delay it by 30+ seconds to improve user experience.
Verify Google Business Profile phone numbers
Ensure the phone number on GBP matches the website for Tyler and all other locations.
Add business hours to all location pages
Clear, consistent hours on each location page improves user experience and local SEO.
References
- [1]
- [2]
- [3]
- [4]
- [5]
- [6]
- [7]Industry Benchmark: Average Orthodontic Case Value ($4,000-$6,000)
- [8]Industry Benchmark: Local Pack Click-Through Rate (70%+ of local searches)
The gap is growing every day
Ready to close the gap?
Every month of inaction means more patients choosing competitors and the review gap widening further. The foundation is strong — now it's time to build on it.